Art and counterculture

Sola Busca tarot: the history and symbols of its 78 cards

A Renaissance deck, usually dated to 1491, reveals how playing-card images become repositories of history, interpretation and mystery.

The Method Files 6 min read

Three cards of geometric designs invented next to a printing block; they are not Sola Busca cards.
Conceptual illustration generated with AI for this reading. It is neither a historical document nor a reconstruction of the object or its functioning.

'Tarot' arrives laden with familiar images: a table, a personal question and a card apparently answering it. These can obstruct an encounter with an old deck: we have assigned its purpose before seeing its figures. Sola Busca invites us to suspend that familiarity. Its characters resist today's familiar tarot repertoire, and its manufacture belongs to a history of paper, printmaking and painting.

Approaching these cards as objects does not eliminate their mystery. It moves them to more concrete questions: who imagined their figures, what a spectator of their time could recognize and why several centuries later we still want to find a complete system behind them.

Paper, ink and colour

The Pinacoteca di Brera guide describes seventy-eight cards: twenty-two trumps and fifty-six divided into coins, swords, batons and cups. Images were printed from burin-engraved plates, then illuminated with tempera and gold. Based on now-damaged inscriptions, the museum places their colouring in Venice in 1491. Trumps include Roman and biblical figures; pip cards also carry elaborate imagery. The exhibition interprets part of this repertoire through Renaissance Hermetic and alchemical culture. Brera Guide, paragraphs 3 and 5.

Keep two operations visible. Engraving permits repetition; illumination adds work to each print. 'A deck' can conceal several crafts and visual decisions. Outlines belong to one phase, colours to another. Asking for an author requires specifying which intervention we mean.

This also changes reproduction. A printed image need not be identical to every other example. One plate can produce impressions with different subsequent finishes. An old card's relationship between series and singularity cannot be reduced to either term alone.

A knight difficult to identify

The British Museum holds uncoloured impressions. Its Knight of Swords entry describes a partly naked rider raising an enormous sword, with a leafless tree behind him. He bears the name AMONE, but identification is uncertain. Attribution to Nicola di Maestro Antonio is also questioned: the catalogue says the arguments are not entirely convincing. It retains 1491 as the date while explaining difficulties with the inscriptions used to establish it. British Museum entry 1845,0825.485.

The oversized sword offers a starting point for composition without immediately turning it into prediction. Arm, body and mount construct force; the name suggests historical identity. But a possible identity is not a settled biography. The card supplies information at different levels, not all equally easy to interpret.

An unknown name produces a particular temptation: to complete what is missing with the story that best fits. Here it is worth keeping the interval between recognizing letters and recognizing a person. The inscription is part of the object; the identification needs additional arguments. The space between the two is work for the history of art, not a defect that must be concealed.

Playing wasn't reading fate.

The Folger Shakespeare Library places the first Italian tarots in the history of card games and explains that its systematic association with divination is much later, developed towards the end of the 18th century. Its collection even retains re-used cards to reinforce the binding of a book: a material path away from the solemnity with which we can contemplate them today. Elizabeth DeBold, Fortune’s Fools.

This does not force us to imagine a Renaissance without symbols or religious speculation. A game can incorporate cultured references, satire, historical memory or philosophical ideas. The problem arises when it is assumed that every symbolic image must have functioned as an answer to the future of the one who held it. Between containing meanings and serving a concrete divinatory practice there is a distance that requires documentation.

An everyday comparison helps: recognising a mythological figure in a painting does not prove it was a cult object. Commission, location and use matter. Cards' portability and rearrangeable images multiply reinterpretations without dating them by themselves.

The Secret as Hypothesis

Brera's Hermetic-alchemical proposal deserves consideration as an argued historical interpretation, neither mere decoration nor a universal key. Catalogues preserve differing judgements: the Petit Palais dates a Bocho impression to 1491–1523 and retains Ferrara as its place of production. Read beside Brera, it shows how a short date beneath an image can condense a lengthy debate. Paris Musées, Bocho.

Consider ordering a series. An explanation may convince for one card but much less for the next. A fixed number of pieces encourages the hope that each will occupy its proper slot. Yet a physically complete deck does not guarantee complete knowledge for interpreting it.

Surveying Metropolitan Museum holdings, librarian Maria Schurr connects Sola Busca with a contemporary book seeking its supposed esoteric secrets. That wording records a current interpretation and interest, not a solved code. Her survey also includes modern decks for other purposes, such as imagining activist projects. The format continues to acquire functions. The Met, It’s in the Cards.

A later reading can inspire works and produce practices. What it does not by itself is return to the workshop of the 15th century and become the documented intention of its authors. The reception adds history to the object; it does not erase the temporal distance between their different lives.

An open deck

Sola Busca holds together material precision and imaginative freedom. We can know its manufacturing techniques while doubting a figure's identity, study a symbolic programme without claiming prediction, and enjoy strangeness without requiring personal advice.

That resistance is part of its interest. The seventy-eight cards are no ready-made dictionary. Their apparent familiarity breaks down before their names, bodies and attributes. The more fruitful question may be not what they announce for us, but what relationships they enabled their makers and later viewers to imagine.

Sources and references