History and symbols

The witches of Zugarramurdi: the 1610 trial and its memory

Between the 1610 process, printed stories and a museum dedicated to victims, a place learns to tell a story that has also become attractive to tourists.

The Method Files 5 min read

Open logbook with empty pages next to a file box on a table.
Conceptual illustration generated with AI. It does not reproduce an inquisitorial process, a file or a Zugarramurdi document.

The cave offers an immediate image. An open space in the rock, crossed by water, seems to contain in advance all the scenes that the visitor has come to look for. Zugarramurdi’s official presentation describes it as a superficial karstic complex and places there, expressly in the land of legend, the celebration of the akelarres. That small precision changes the visit: the cavity exists; the scenes we imagine inside have another history. Tourism Zugarramurdi, the cave.

The landscape can give shape to a story without demonstrating it. A shadow between stone walls has a visual force that a written statement does not possess. When the name of the place is already accompanied by the word “witches”, it is easy to feel that the rock confirms what we have heard. But the historical journey begins precisely where that impression ceases to suffice.

A village's name, a punishment's setting

Government of Navarre historical material dates the proceedings' beginning to January 1609, following accounts and confessions in Zugarramurdi and Urdax. It names inquisitors Alonso Becerra, Juan de Valle Alvarado and the later-arriving Alonso de Salazar y Frías. In Logroño's November 1610 auto-da-fé, six people were burned alive and five in effigy. Persecution extended beyond the village whose name became associated with it. Government of Navarre, Zugarramurdi: the Great Persecution.

Popular shorthand can erase the distance between Zugarramurdi and Logroño. The village's name concentrates memory while public punishment took place elsewhere. This requires considering movement, custody and decisions outside the accused people's everyday lives. The whole history does not fit inside a cave.

'Witches' does not describe people by itself. Here it carries accusation and later memory. Saying 'accused of witchcraft' preserves the difference between attributed acts and the lives subjected to proceedings. Their harm does not require accepting the powers alleged in those accounts.

When an accusation becomes a scene

A narration of night meetings has characters, actions and places. It can offer the reader a complete picture even when the relationship between that image and events is uncertain. The more details it contains, the easier it can be to remember it. That ease does not amount to a check.

The cultural consequence is troubling: alleged scenes circulate more easily than the accused people's biographies. Flight, gatherings and the devil are memorable; ordinary days, family conversations and what each person wished to say are far less known. Spectacular accusation enjoys a narrative advantage over the lives it displaces.

It is not appropriate to fill this void with a reassuring collective biography. To turn all persecuted persons into herbalists, rebels or guardians of a secret religion would give an answer that is too uniform. The restitution of their humanity can begin by admitting the diversity that a label does not allow to recover.

The journey of history through the printing press

Eva Lara Alberola studies how printed accounts from 1611 and their later reception fixed Zugarramurdi in cultural memory. Her research on eighteenth- and nineteenth-century newspapers identifies renewed impetus in 1811, when Juan de Mongastón's text was reissued with notes by Leandro Fernández de Moratín. The place remained a reference for witchcraft long after the proceedings. University of Cadiz, research by Lara Alberola.

Moving from tribunal to print changes the story's scale. Readers need not know neighbours or distances between houses. They can receive a portable, bounded narrative for discussing superstition, authority or credulity.

A reissue adds another voice. The old text remains, but a later reader frames it. Notes may challenge, satirise or highlight formerly solemn claims. A narrative changes function without losing all its details, circulating even as the convictions behind it change.

A place's fame therefore depends not only on events but on later narrators, selections and media of circulation. Zugarramurdi's name combines historical experience with a long narrative afterlife.

A museum that asks to remember

The Witches' Museum states that it aims to preserve the proceedings' memory and honour the men and women who suffered. It contrasts this purpose with stereotypes and offers a journey through contemporary society, myths and legends. It also includes a contemporary installation by Agurtzane Anduetza. Official presentation of the museum.

This creates productive tension. Visitors may arrive attracted by a fantastic figure and encounter accused people. A recognisable name opens a less comfortable history than a promised night of mystery. Curiosity need not disappear; its object can change.

Cave and museum offer complementary movements: one places the body within a landscape; the other examines the mediation that made it a stage. Neither requires imagination to stop. The question is what we do with it when an accusation's consequences become visible.

Stories have taught us to imagine night gatherings. Making room for people who did not choose to become their characters is harder. Remembering them means resisting a scene so tidy that every victim ends up performing a role written by others.

What's left on the way out

Zugarramurdi retains more than a localized legend. It retains the possibility of observing how a name passes from the accusation to the book and from the book to the visit. Each step can repeat an image or give it a different meaning.

The cave will continue to invite you to look towards the darkness. History also allows you to look at those who were locked in a word. Between both attentions there is room for a cultural visit that does not need to turn suffering into decoration or renounce the interest that the stories arouse.

Sources and references